The Mill at Sutter's

leanneg geiger

5 months ago · ★ 5

This place is amazing!! Everything I’ve tried so far was great: wings, cheesesteak sandwich, burger, French onion soup, penne vodka, hot dogs. Can’t wait to go back for more! I think it's well priced considering the quality and quantity of food you receive. You pay $18 for fried rice these days - so I think the prices are on par. The cocktails and the live music put this place over the top! The owner is very friendly and I loved the new renovations! Definitely one of my favorite go-to spots for lunch/dinner!

Yema Monroe

4 months ago · ★ 3

★★★☆☆ The service was one of the best parts of our visit. The wait staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome throughout the meal. Food-wise, it was a mixed experience. The branzino was fresh and cooked well, the wings were enjoyable with the sauces served on the side, and the chili dog was flavorful. The broccoli was prepared nicely, and the Lemon New York Cheesecake was an excellent way to end the meal—creamy, rich, and just the right balance of sweet and tart. Unfortunately, the salmon did not seem as fresh as expected and left an itchy sensation on my tongue and mouth. The fries were overly salty, while the coleslaw lacked flavor and could use more seasoning. Overall, there were several standout dishes and great service, but the inconsistencies in some of the food made this an average dining experience.

Sean Muradia

2 months ago · ★ 5

It was a wonderful experience! Our server Caite was very attentive and fulfilled all our requests with a grace and smile. Food was phenomenal and full of flavors. I would highly recommend this place and special thank you to Caite for making our visit pleasant. Would definitely return to try more items on the menu.

Ivette Aguilera

5 months ago · ★ 5

Still thinking about this meal… every bite felt intentional, every flavor perfectly balanced. From the first course to the last sip, it wasn’t just dinner—it was an experience. Live music set the perfect vibe, and the owner was incredibly friendly and attentive, making everyone feel right at home. Impeccable service, stunning presentation, and dishes that genuinely surprised me. Safe to say, this spot just set a new standard.

Nadia Merhai

5 months ago · ★ 5

Great renovation on the place and the food! The only ask I would have is to expand the cheesesteak options to chicken and vegetarian. Would round out their menu pretty well but still, a perfect start