Colony Sandwich Company

Dameon Locklear

5 months ago · ★ 5

Everybody loves a great sandwich, right? I am always on the lookout for an outstanding Reuben sandwich. Their 'Hot Mess Reuben' was far from a hot mess. I felt put together after my experience. The rye bread with pastrami or corned beef, hot melty Swiss over sauerkraut, and just the right amount of thousand island dressing is a flavor combination that can be challenging to balance. Colony Sandwich Company nailed it. I finally had the opportunity to try this place and was NOT disappointed. So tasty and freshly made. Service was fast and friendly. Moderate menu prices. Open air atmosphere in the heart of downtown Atascadero, CA. You have to try this spot. I cannot wait to go back!

Beatriz Almeida

a year ago · ★ 5

Adorable place downtown, with food and service that match the great ambiance. There's toys for kids, corn hole, tables with umbrellas, without umbrellas, indoor seating, and bar stools. You have a big variety. And the menu is incredibly delicious. Everything we tried was so good. The fries especially - and one order is huge so plenty for two to share and have some left! Patty melt was divine and Reuben excellent. It came out a little slowly but it wasn't a bad wait.

KDG

a year ago · ★ 4

Stopped in Atascadero for a quick brunch on the way to Disney. First impressions were good. A nice outdoor patio area and the inner dining area was a quaint and had a nice vibe. Lots of great choices to choose from. The sandwich we ordered was a bit heavy on the mustard, but delicious nonetheless. We also ordered some tenders for the rugrats. Also, a side of coleslaw. Total came to $31.38 before tip. Kind of stiff. Far too expensive for this family.

Tori Martinez

4 months ago · ★ 5

I like the vibe a lot, the tables outside are really nice, but they have a little area inside with AC for when it gets too hot. The food is delicious too - I recommend the reuben, the poblano, and the blackened fish sandwiches! The fries are well-seasoned too

Carrie Anne

6 months ago · ★ 5

Wonderful atmosphere inside or outside, rad kids play area near the outside tables & gluten free options-one of my favorite go to places!